'This can't be right': Big sharks found in waters far from the open ocean

Two shark species have appeared in inland U.S. waters more than 180 miles from their usual coastal hunting grounds, surprising fishermen and shocking scientists.

Now scientists have found eleven broadnose sevengill sharks near the Washington state capital of Olympia, along with a critically endangered soupfin shark.

Only one broadnose sevengill shark had previously been reported in the inland waters now called the Salish Sea, the 6,500-square-mile body of inland water that stretches from Washington’s Puget Sound to British Columbia’s Vancouver Island. And that was in 1993.

No one realized the two species were in Washington state's Puget Sound until 2021 when a local fisherman posted a picture of a shark he'd pulled out of the water near the tiny town of Shelton, Washington.

Washington State's Department of Fish and Wildlife saw it and thought it was a similar shark that's common in the area: the bluntnose sixgill shark.

That shark is illegal to fish, in part because it can be so dangerous. They were going to send someone out to give the fisherman a citation when marine biologists took another look at the photo.

"I looked at the picture and said, 'This can't be right,'" said Dayv Lowry, a natural resources specialist with the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration in Olympia.

It wasn't a sixgill shark at all but an entirely different species, the broadnose sevengill shark, and it was very far away from where it should have been.

"We thought it was just a fluke," said Jessica Schulte, a PhD candidate in the Big Fish Lab at Oregon State University who studies sharks.

A joint team of scientists from her university, Washington's Department of Fish and Wildlife and NOAA all went out looking the next spring. Far from being a wild goose chase, they caught two of the sharks – which can reach ten feet and 400 pounds – in just two hours.

"When we saw it come up there was a lot of hooting and hollering," said Lowry.

Schulte remembers thinking, "What are you doing here?' There's been over 200 years of commercial fishing in the region and no one's ever seen one that far in."

The discovery came in a tangle of waterways at the far southern portion of Puget Sound. The shark was pulled up by a fisherman on Hammersley Inlet, a body of water so narrow you can throw a rock across it.

The sevengill wasn't the only surprising find.

"The fisherman had also posted a photo of a soupfin shark, which is critically endangered," said Ethan Personius, a graduate student in Oregon State University’s Big Fish Lab. "And we found them too."

The two out-of-place sharks share quite a bit in common.

The broadnose sevengill and the soupfin sharks typically live along the Pacific coast, from as far south as Baja California in Mexico to as far north as British Columbia in Canada. While they like to hang out in coastal estuaries in the summer when there's lots of prey for them to eat, neither was known to populate far-inland waters.

Until now.

The soupfin shark can grow up to six feet long and weigh as much as 60 pounds. It is not considered dangerous to humans. As its name suggests, its fins were at one time considered a delicacy. It was also heavily fished for its liver in the 1930s and 1940s, when shark liver oil was a popular way to supplement vitamin A in the diet.

New apex predators in the water

These two apex predators are new, unexpected and seemed to be following food as the ecosystem of Puget Sound changes, driven in part by multiple marine heat wave events, said Schulte.

Called "the Blob," the first of the extraordinary ocean heatwaves that began in 2014 have been scrambling longstanding ecosystems.

Salmon runs are declining and bait fish populations typically found in the area are shifting. Northern anchovy populations out in the ocean moved inshore to escape the warmer water. "Suddenly we had more anchovy than anybody could remember," said Lowry.

"It’s possible these sharks are moving into these areas to take advantage of favorable climate conditions and new prey resources," Personius said.

Common along the coast but not the Sound

The broadnose sevengill and the soupfin are common along the Pacific coast from Mexico up to Canada but there's no record of them ever appearing deep in Puget Sound, an inland waterway that runs from Tacoma to north of Seattle.

"We scoured our records going back a hundred years and they were never recorded here beyond one validated sighting," said Lowry. "This species is now several hundred miles from where it's ever been documented," he said.

The good news is there's no danger to humans. While the sevengill is a powerful swimmer that can be aggressive if provoked, there are no records of it attacking humans, according to the Monterey Bay Aquarium.

A major question for scientists is what the sharks are eating, because that will tell them whether this new influx is going to further change the area's marine ecosystem.

The sevengill find seals and sea lions tasty treats.

"They're one of the few shark species that prey upon marine mammals," said Schulte. "In other locations around the world they've been seen teaming up to take down sea lions."

But for the moment no one knows if that's what they're chowing down on. "Do they eat 10 or 15 seals over the course of the season? Does that make a dent in the seal population? Or are they foraging more for crab? We honestly don't know," said Lowry.

To find out, the researchers are resorting to the decidedly unglamorous task of pumping the animals' stomachs, then tagging them and quickly releasing them back in the water.

Perhaps the biggest mystery is one the three groups — academic, state and federal — are all working together to solve: how are these sharks getting in and out of Puget Sound?

The 180 miles between the Strait of Juan de Fuca, which leads from the Pacific into Puget Sound, all the way to Hammersley Inlet is hardly uncharted territory. It's home to extensive commercial and recreational fishing, marine surveys, academic research sites and multiple underwater microphones to pick up the noise of tagged sharks swimming by.

And yet so far, no one has seen either sevengill or soupfin sharks making their way out to the ocean or back down to the Inlet again, even though they seem to only spend the summers there.

"It's just wild. How do they get there without someone finding them?" said Lowry. "We're all digging in to try to figure out what this mystery is all about."